In an increasingly competitive academic environment, it’s easy to fall into the trap of equating education with grades alone. While good marks can open doors to opportunities, true education encompasses far more. Home tuition, often viewed as a tool for academic improvement, has the potential to nurture emotional intelligence, self-discipline, and a love for learning. It’s time to reimagine home tuition as a holistic development platform rather than just a grade-boosting machine.
The Limitations of a Grades-Only Approach
Grades represent only a narrow aspect of a student’s abilities. They rarely reflect creativity, critical thinking, or emotional intelligence. Focusing solely on marks can create undue pressure and lead students to lose interest in subjects they might otherwise enjoy.
Why Home Tuition Should Be About More Than Grades
Here’s why home tuition should go beyond just academic performance:
Learning at One’s Own Pace: Home tuition allows for personalized teaching that adapts to the student’s speed and understanding. Tutors can clarify doubts, revisit tough topics, and accelerate lessons as needed. This builds confidence and mastery over memorization.
Developing Critical Thinking Skills: A good home tutor incorporates real-world examples, encourages discussions, and promotes logical reasoning. These practices help develop problem-solving and analytical thinking.
Encouraging Curiosity and Independent Learning: The right tutor acts as a mentor, sparking curiosity and a love for learning by encouraging questions and deep exploration of topics.
Building Self-Esteem and Motivation: Personalized attention allows tutors to motivate students and turn mistakes into learning opportunities, helping build confidence and resilience.
Enhancing Communication Skills: One-on-one sessions allow students to express themselves more freely and build effective communication habits that benefit them in academic and professional settings.
Teaching Life Skills: Home tuition can be a platform for teaching important life skills like time management, accountability, and goal setting.
Parental Involvement: Regular feedback from home tutors allows parents to stay updated on both academic and personal development.
How TheTuitionTeacher Goes Beyond Grades
TheTuitionTeacher is a home tuition platform that understands the value of holistic education. Here’s how they stand out:
Personalized Tutor Matching: Students are matched with tutors who suit their learning style, academic needs, and personality.
Emphasis on Conceptual Clarity: TheTuitionTeacher promotes understanding rather than rote learning, helping students build strong conceptual foundations.
Progress Tracking: Parents receive regular feedback and reports to track academic and personal growth.
Empowered Tutors: Tutors aren’t just educators—they are mentors trained to support emotional and intellectual development.
Flexible Learning Options: With online and offline classes available, TheTuitionTeacher adapts to each student’s schedule and preferences.
Conclusion: Redefining the Role of Home Tuition
While grades are important, they are not the sole measure of a student’s potential. Home tuition should foster a well-rounded individual by nurturing curiosity, resilience, emotional intelligence, and communication skills. TheTuitionTeacher is pioneering this shift by offering personalized, supportive, and holistic tutoring that puts the child’s overall development at the center.
To delve into a project concept, it’s important to cultivate your idea by identifying potential starting points, as mentioned in the book PBL in Elementary Grades.
The information for project ideas is from the following in this blog:
PBL IN THE ELEMENTARY GRADES Step-by-Step Guidance, Tools and Tips for Standards-Focused K-5 Projects book suggests to look at the standards.
Trevor Muir, author of 5 ways to Engage PBL Project Ideas, suggests 5 tips to developing PBL Project Ideas.
Develop an idea
PBL In Elementary Grades book reminds us of a good project includes significant content and 21st Century Skills features and they are:
Significant Content. At its core, the project focuses on teaching students’ important knowledge and skills, derived from standards and key concepts at the heart of academic subject areas.
21st Century Skills. Students build skills valuable for today’s world, such as critical thinking/problem solving, collaboration, and communication, which are taught and assessed.
In-depth inquiry. Students are engaged in a rigorous, extended process of asking questions, using resources, and developing answers.
Driving Question. Project work is focused on an open-ended question that students explore or capture the task they are completing.
Need to know. Students see the need to gain knowledge, understand concepts, and apply skills in order to answer the Driving Question and create project products, beginning with an Entry Event that generates interest and curiosity.
Voice and choice. Students can make some choices about the products to be created, how they work, and how they use their time, guided by the teacher, depending on age level and PBL experience.
Revision and reflection. The project includes processes for students to use feedback to consider additions and changes that lead to high-quality products and think about what and how they are learning.
Public audience. Students present their work to other people, beyond their classmates and teacher.
Places to Start Explore Project Idea
The book suggests looking at the standards you teach. You want to ask yourself, as you read through your standards documents and curriculum guides, “Which are the more complex standards — the ones where students need to show in-depth understanding or apply what they’re learning?” Those are the best candidates for projects. Here are some examples the book provided:
Science Standard (K): “Students know objects can be described in terms of the material they are made of and their physical properties (e.g., color, size, shape, weight, texture, flexibility, attraction to magnets, floating, sinking).”
Potential project: To demonstrate the physical properties and characteristics of various materials that everyday objects are made of, kindergarten students create and host interactive displays for the school’s “Science Night” using toys, clothing, and other common objects found in the home.
Social Studies Standard (1st grade): “The student understands the concepts of goods and services. The student is expected to: identify examples of goods and services in the home, school, and community; identify ways people exchange goods and services.”
Potential project: Students interview their parents and visit various businesses near the school to find out what and how they buy and sell, make a map showing local business locations, then create and operate a “flea market” in their classroom.
Science Standard (2nd grade): “Describe how animals may use plants, or other animals, for food, shelter and nesting.”
Potential project: Students are placed in the role of scientists in a fictitious scenario in which various plant species in a local ecosystem are threatened by pests and disease, and try to predict the effects on the ecosystem if they disappear from it.
Math Standard (3rd grade): “Formulate questions that can be addressed with data and collect, organize, and display relevant data to answer them.”
Potential project: Students measure the wind in the field behind their school by designing and building a simple anemometer to answer the question, “Is it windy enough here for a wind turbine to create enough energy to power our classroom?”
English/Language Arts Standard (4th grade): “Compare and contrast the treatment of similar themes and topics (e.g., opposition of good and evil) and patterns of events (e.g., the quest) in stories, myths, and traditional literature from different cultures.”
Potential project: Students showcase stories from various cultures with written commentary, comparing and contrasting them on the website pages they create.
Social Studies Standard (5th grade): “Draw upon data to describe the experience of immigrant groups.”
Potential project: Students capture the experience of a child immigrating to America by using information gathered from stories, maps, interviews, and diaries to write and perform a play.
Trevor Muir, author of 5 ways to Come Up with Engaging PBL Project Ideas, suggests 5 tips to developing PBL Project Ideas. Muir, who is a teacher, author, and speaker, has 10 years of experience with Project Based Learning. As a former teacher myself, I would use his 5 tips for developing PBL project ideas. See below for Muir explanations of the 5 tips:
Create a List of Problems
Alter Existing Project Ideas to Fit Your Classroom
Identify a Theme Within Your Power Standards
Brainstorm With Other Educators
Use Your Network to Find Authentic Partners
Create a List of Problems:
One of the best ways to come up with a project idea for a specific unit of instruction is to first ignore that unit of instruction. It can be easier to brainstorm project ideas when the academic standards do not encumber you that must be covered. Instead, create a list of problems that your students could solve in your school and/or community. Be as broad or specific as you want. Consider issues that matter to your students, or you think will be relevant to them once they are introduced to this problem. The list might include items like:
Neighborhood littering
Crowded hallways
Homelessness
old playground equipment
lonely elderly
Kids at Children’s Hospital
Busy Street needing a crosswalk
Once you have this list, you can then begin to consider how to incorporate them into a set of standards or learning unit.
*As a tip, consider what they are passionate about AND what you are passionate about. I’ve found the most successful projects to address problems everyone can be inspired to solve – including the teacher.
Alter Existing Project Ideas to Fit Your Classroom
There is no need to reinvent the wheel. There are thousands of other educators out there who have led their students through Project Based Learning, and thanks to the internet, many of those ideas are available to anyone who searches for them. Some of the best projects my students have ever completed were ones I altered to fit my classroom.
I once had a unit on World War II, so while brainstorming PBL project ideas I Googled, “WW2 PBL Project.” I found a blog post where a teacher wrote about her students interviewing veterans and writing their life stories. Inspired by this, I had my students do the same. However, because most of my students have cell phones with videos cameras, we filmed our interviews and turned them into documentaries. At the end of the project, the students showcased their work at a local theater.
It became one of the most amazing things I’ve ever been a part of, and it all started with a Google search. There are some great resources online with project ideas to borrow for your classes. Check out PBLWorks’ Project Resource, this list from the site TeachThought, or the number of project ideas I often share in my blog.
Another great place to discover existing project ideas is social media. Post a tweet saying something like, “Has anyone ever done a PBL project about geometric shapes?” or “Have you ever found an engaging way to teach students about invasive species?” On Twitter, you can use hashtags like #PBLCHAT, #ELACHAT, #SSCHAT, or #EDCHAT to widen your reach. It sounds crazy, but asking a bunch of strangers for ideas often works in the education world. Whether it’s in PBL Facebook groups or on Teacher-TikTok, teachers all over the place are willing to share their ideas.
Identify a Theme Within Your Power Standards
Sometimes your content standards will have thematic elements to them that can help you generate project ideas. A theme is a universal takeaway from a learning unit, something bigger than just the subject of what students are learning. If you can identify a theme at the start of project planning, you can begin to think about how students will learn that theme.
For instance, let’s say these were standards you were working with:
Industrialization – Analyze the origins, characteristics, and consequences of industrialization across the world by describing the social and economic impact of industrialization.
Increasing global interconnections between societies, through the emergence and spread of ideas, innovations, and commodities.
After analyzing these standards, you could determine that a theme might be, “Industrialization can have a major impact on people and society.” From there, you can begin to brainstorm how students can learn that theme. Ask questions like: Who is being impacted by industrialization right now? Is it happening in our community? Who could my students serve in this project? What can they create to lessen this impact?
Brainstorm With Other Educators
Once you determine a theme or identify a problem for students to solve, find a group of people to brainstorm with. Of course you can come up with ideas on your own, but the best creativity often happens during collaboration. Share the problem, theme, and set of standards with teacher friends at a staff meeting or during a planning period, and start throwing ideas at the wall.
And when I say throw ideas at the wall, I mean literally. Write down every idea, whether it’s crazy or not, on a whiteboard or sticky notes. Forget about what’s possible or reasonable for the constraints of your classroom, and see what people come up with. After a short time, you will start to see a project idea take shape that is possible. For instance, I had these industrialization standards to brainstorm with my peers. At one point someone said, “This reminds me of a documentary I saw about how refugees from developing nations often struggle to adapt to our industrialized society when they arrive in America.”
For the past 10 years I have been leading workshops for teachers on how to plan Project Based Learning projects, and at every single one I ask if anyone knows someone who relates to their local zoo. At every workshop for 10 years, at least one person raises their hand and shares a connection they have with someone at the zoo. I then make the point that if you want to plan a project that has something to do with animals, and you’re looking for an authentic audience, all you must do is ask a group of teachers and someone will be able to connect you with the zoo!
The point is, we all have networks. When coming up with PBL project ideas, we need to take advantage of that. Want your students to present to an official in local government? Someone in your circle probably knows someone who your students could create a project for. Would bringing in a pilot enhance a physics unit? I’m guessing you at least know someone who knows a pilot who could work with your class. Reaching out to friends, family, parents, and colleagues asking for help planning for projects is a great way to come up with ideas and up the authenticity in your classroom.
Muir wished there was a magical formula for coming up with strong project ideas. You just do this, this, and this and you now have a project that will make learning more authentic and engaging for students. But the truth is, coming up with project ideas is a creative process. It requires thinking outside the box and collaborating with others. Ideation might mean searching online and using your network. However, when you do this, when you approach project design with a creative lens, you will come up with engaging projects. And when that happens, learning will be deeper, richer, and dynamic for your students.
If you want to dive deeper into Project Based Learning Check Muir’s epicPBL.com where he has free resources, videos, workshop options, and online courses.
Conclusion
Developing an idea to create a project is the beginning of the PBL project planning process. Other things to consider when you plan a project are:
Deciding on the Scope of the Project
Focusing the Project on Content Standards and 21st Century Skills
Deciding What Major Products Will be Created and How They Will be Presented
Hallermann, Sara; Larmer, John; Mergendoller PhD, John. PBL in the Elementary Grades: Step-by-Step Guidance, Tools and Tips for Standards-Focused K-5 Projects. Buck Institute for Education. Kindle Edition.
SCRUM tools support Scrum ceremonies, including planning sprints, keeping track of daily work, refining backlogs, and using data from the past to keep improving. When people work together on these tasks, Scrum tools help them stay focused by connecting the work to its value.
If you are a teacher who works on projects with students in PBL, you know that PBL can be messy and hard to track due to the multi-step process. Todd LaVogue, a design thinking teacher at the Conservatory School in North Palm Beach, Florida, knows all too well. LaVogue, author of Why I Scrum: Using a Project Management Tool for PBL article, had difficulty keeping track of every student, every task, and every PBL project management process.
LaVogue saw a sitcom about a tech startup in Silicon Valley trying to get their product ready for consumer use, with a deadline approaching. LaVogue saw one frantic scene where the team started grabbing post it notes off a white board, working on the task written on the post it, and moving tasks from left to right through various columns on the white board. LaVogue began researching about this magical board online, and he loved that no scrum board images were the same. He began to change to a scrum board to fit the needs of his students.
Scrum Board Process in PBL
LaVogue felt no need to overcomplicate the process since scrum boards are configurable. LaVogue has this iteration with five columns:
Team
To Do
Doing
Peer Review
Done
Heading
Team names or Deliverable names
Individual tasks on note cards or post it notes
Tasks remove from To Do column and return as Doing
Members of another team give cool or warm feedback
Peer group initial the task card as complete and return to Done column.
Information
Team Column: Only team name or deliverable names are listed.
Reason: LaVogue had no interest in student progress monitor boards. LaVogue did not want to confuse any classroom guests into thinking that is displayed.
To Do Column: Teams create individual tasks on notecards (cut in half to conserve board space) or post it notes. All tasks start in “To Do” section. Once removed from the board to work on, that card returns to board in the Doing column.
LaVogue helped teams to create list of all tasks necessary to complete deliverables.
Peer Review Column: Before tasks are moved to Done column, members of another team will analyze the work and provide warm and cool feedback.
Done Column: Once the peer group initials the task card as complete, the card is placed in the Done column.
LaVogue wanted to keep the scrum board idea fresh for his students, so he had created scrum boards using various materials and designs, while keeping the five columns the same.
LaVogue believed on “large scale, multi-step projects, scrum boards are an excellent way to keep students on track.
LaVogue and his students modeled when you are not currently working on a task, to approach the scrum board and select a task. This is one way to ensure everyone has something to do.
Real-World Application in PBL
In LaVogue opinion the use of scrum boards across many companies adds another level of real-world application. LaVogue believed peer review is the most important column on the board for his students. Students looked for feedback to find out what revision is necessary on their task. Students gave feedback work on important thinking and communication skills.
LaVogue explained that once the task has gone through peer review and revised to the satisfaction of all involved, sign off is completed and moved into the final column. LaVogue noted “The sense of student ownership in creating the tasks, teams and deliverables makes the scrum board the focal point of student-centered learning.”
LaVogue typically works with large group of kids during a PBL cycle. LaVogue believes scrum board helps him to keep track of all the teams. LaVogue looks over the scrum board a few times during classes to identify ways he can help.
LaVogue gives an example of a task for one team that could be to create a 3D printed project. LaVogue will check to ensure the team has all the tools and/or skills to complete that task.
On exhibition night, students develop ownership of their learning and ownership of their deliverables. LaVogue need not create some exaggerated reason students are doing what they are doing. The students created task. The students created teams. The students created deliverables.
LaVogue has become a guide to help kids develop the skills to make it all happen.
Scrum Board Example
LaVogue provides one example of what goes on in scrum board for his class. Driving question for a Project:
It focuses on locally threatened or endangered wildlife. Students want to create video games to educate the public about specific species that interest them.
Task Examples:
Students would create tasks and add to the “To Do” column of their scrum board, and they are:
And more —
Give Scrum Board a Try
LaVogue points out scrum board has helped his students stay focused and organized. A scrum board helps them to visualize their plan. It helps them see the big things can be done with a plan and an understanding that it is a multi-step process to reach the finish line.
Carl Slater, author of Nurturing Mistake Tolerance in the Classroom article, suggests 3 ways to build mistake tolerance in the classroom by:
Use Jigsaw Activities
Guide students to Get the GIST
Actively Model Critical Thinking
Slater points out that “Teachers can help students get over the fear of making a mistake by showing them that errors are just a part of the learning process.” Students do not like making mistakes in front of their peers. Same goes for the adults. Slater mentions this dislike leads to an avoidance of failure to preserve self-identity and efficacy. Slater defines it as “fear branding” which is the perception of being outed by one’s community as incompetent.
Slater emphasizes this fear can lead down trauma spiral of internalized inadequacies, classroom disruptions, and other barriers undermining their confidence as learners. As a result outlook can last a lifetime, limiting individuals’ horizons and opportunities. Students who already faced stereotypes about their educational capacity may face more pronounced effects.
One of the goals of educators is to teach students what to do when they don’t know what to do. Slater explains that practitioners see real value in putting knowledge into action. Practitioners believe to get past the problems brought up in knowledge, teachers need to use practice-based lessons that help students learn how to solve problems.
Slater refers to learning is messy. The trial and error doesn’t always go in the right direction (for example, starting and stopping, pausing, being confused, writing and revising), requires a mistake tolerance must be nurtured in the classroom. Students need to learn how to accept mistakes in the classroom. As a student’s patience grows, they not only accept that making mistakes is a normal part of learning, but they also see the value in them. This helps them become expert learners.
Slater suggests 3 ways to grow mistake tolerance in students:
Use jigsaw activities. These activities break up complex text into smaller, disjointed chunks that students work collaboratively to piece together, creating coherence and meaning. Arranging ideas and/or events chronologically, logically, or sequentially requires a grit for trial and error that expert learners sometimes take for granted. Jigsaw activities create opportunities for students to gain confidence by justifying their ordering by experimentation, negotiating text meaning, and identifying target language.
First, I introduce this activity to students using comic strips. Students practice shuffling comic strip panels in the correct order by identifying key story elements (e.g. plot, setting, characters, point of view, theme). I then increase the rigor by tasking students to correctly sequence reading passage sections, using the same story-element identification.
This tactile approach to text engagement mirrors that of puzzling. Like puzzles, the comic strip panels or text sections within the jigsaw activity are in pieces that must be assembled properly. Manipulating the puzzle parts and figuring out where they fit within the larger picture requires problem-solving perseverance as students develop their abilities to plan and test ideas. From a social and emotional standpoint, completing jigsaw activities also helps students learn how to accept challenges, overcome problems, and deal with the frustrations of failure.
2. Guide students to get the GIST. These activities are summarizing exercises that help students focus on main ideas. Developed by James Cunningham, PhD, in 1982, GIST (Generating Interactions between Schemata and Texts) helps students improve reading comprehension and increase recall of complex texts. As the name suggests, GIST scaffolds the removal of extraneous detail as students evaluate and create information to convey the crux of what they read. It’s an adaptable strategy that can be used with many informational and literary texts and is an effective tool to use in content areas.
Students read a text and respond to the six common journalists’ questions on the GIST template (who, what, when, where, why, and how). Using their responses, students identify the most important information by paring down the text into summaries of 20 words or less (the teacher predefines the GIST word count).
As students work to comply with the word constraint, you will notice the messiness of trial and error as students change their summaries to fit the predefined parameter. Students build mistake tolerance in low-stakes routines using various combinations of elaborative rehearsal, reorganization, and contextualized language.
3. Actively model critical thinking. To create a classroom culture open to mistakes, teachers must not only embrace them among students, but also actively model their own tolerance for mistakes. We should want our students to see that we, too, wrestle with getting ideas down on paper. Follow a plan to ensure you’re modeling the thinking you intended. Stay in character as a learner, not a teacher.
For example, imagine that you’re working through a text or a task for the first time. Model the thinking you expect from the students. Like a good learner, ask yourself questions, and verbalize inner dialogue.
What is the author trying to tell me? Is that a clue about what’s going to happen next? What happens next if I do this? Is this getting me closer to my goal?
Narrate actions you’re about to do, such as “I’d better write that down” or “That didn’t work. I’d better erase that step and start over.” Let students see and hear you struggle with your thinking. Students also need to see the strategies that good learners use to overcome challenges. It’s important for them to see that all learners encounter challenges and that it’s OK. So not only verbalize struggle but model the metacognitive and critical-thinking strategies that good learners use for overcoming challenges. Try modeling perseverance by building in some unsuccessful attempts and giving yourself a little pep talk after each one.
Conclusion
Slater describes learning is an ongoing process that includes practicing, making changes, and improving. The process of trial and error can be fun to learn if students are given the right tools and knowledge at the start. Experience, which usually means learning the right way to do something by making mistakes along the way, is what makes us learn. It’s also one of the main reasons experienced learners are motivated.
First PBL Project needs to be modest in scope to achieve the best result. Andrew Miller stresses that if you are just getting started with Project Based Learning, “Don’t Go Crazy”. Miller’s article “Getting Started with Project-Based Learning (Hint: Don’t Go Crazy)” suggests a few things to consider if you are just started with PBL:
Limited Scope:
Try to focus on two or three priority standards for your first project. Concentrate the learning on one subject rather than multiple disciplines. Aim for a two-to-three-week project, or approximately 10 to 15 contact hours.
In addition to limiting the time, you might consider narrowing choice. Instead of many product options, offer a short menu. Allow students to choose how they want to work but choose the teams for the project yourself. There are many ways to build voice and choice into a project, but these aspects can be limited.
By narrowing the scope of a project, teachers and their students can have short-term success that builds stamina for more complex projects later.
Plan Early:
One of the challenges of PBL, but also one of the joys, is the planning process. In PBL, you plan up front, and it does take a significant amount of time. You need to plan assessments and scaffolds and gather resources to support project learning.
While you might be able to do some of this during scheduled planning time, ask your leadership for creative structures to carve out time for planning. Perhaps staff meetings can be used for this time, or release days can be offered.
It is important to get ahead and feel prepared for and confident about a project. By using the backward design process, you can effectively map out a project that is ready to go in the classroom.
Once you plan, you can differentiate instruction and meet the needs of your students, rather than being in permanent crisis mode trying to figure out what will happen tomorrow.
Gather Feedback:
When you have a great project planned, contact colleagues both digitally and in person to get feedback. This can be done through posting an idea on X or having a gallery walk of ideas, where teachers walk your project gallery and leave feedback on Post-its. If you can, have a 30-minute conversation with a teacher colleague or instructional coach.
Main Course, Not Dessert:
It is easy in a short-term project to fall into the trap of a “dessert” project that isn’t necessarily inquiry based. With PBL, the project itself is the learning- it’s the “main course.” In fact, many teachers who think they are doing PBL are actually doing project. In PBL you are teaching through the project-not teaching and then doing the project.
Use an effective PBL project checklist to ensure a high-quality experience, while still keeping a narrow focus and timeline. It helps ensure that you focus on aspects such as inquiry, voice and choice, and significant content.
Commit to Reflection:
We are all learners, and when we start something new, we start small, limiting our focus to help us master the bigger thing step by step. A key aspect of this is that when you finish a project, you should take time to reflect on it.
Consider journaling, having a dialogue with an instructional coach, or following a structured reflection protocol with a team of teachers.
Through reflection, projects become better and may live on for many years, so that reflection time pays off with time saved on subsequent runs through the project.
Tips From the Classroom
From PBL in the Elementary Grades Step-by-Step Guidance book provides the following tips:
First Project? Modest is Best
A project ambitious in scope might last a month or more. It would involve multiple subjects and complex products, community outreach, presentations to a large public audience, advanced technology…but if this is your first project, you don’t need to go there yet. You might want to get comfortable with the basics of PBL first. Here’s what we advise for a modest first project:
2 weeks in duration
1 curricular area of focus (with integrated literacy standards)
limited complexity and number of student products
takes place completely in the classroom, does not include trips into the community
Hallermann, Sara; Larmer, John; Mergendoller PhD, John. PBL in the Elementary Grades: Step-by-Step Guidance, Tools and Tips for Standards-Focused K-5 Projects (p. 28). Buck Institute for Education. Kindle Edition.
When designing a PBL Project, your focus is to teach students academic content area knowledge and skills drawn from district or state standards. Your project also focuses on building students’ ability to think critically, solve problems, collaborate, and communicate (3Cs), which are the 21st Century skills students need to prepare for life and work in today’s world, according to PBL in the Elementary Grades book.
The book provides a project overview planning form. See below
On the form, it indicates which standards and skills you are targeting for your project.
Selecting Content Standards for Your Project
You are good to go if you have come up with your project ideas by starting from your standards. It is important to remember to align your project with standards.
Standards that are most important are called “priority standards” that are identify by your school or district you want to use as the focus for your project. Priority standards are often based on what items appear more frequently on state tests.
If priority standards have not been identified, you can decide for yourself or with colleagues in your grade level what the priority standards are for the content areas included in the project.
To Start the Alignment Process:
First decide on the few standards that are most essential for meeting the goals of the project. It is not a good idea to try to include as many standards as possible in the project since students will ne spending so much time on it. Typically, a project should focus only 1 – 3 standards from each academic content area to be included, depending on how specific standards are written.
If you try to include too many standards, you cannot teach them in any depth and assess them adequately.
PBL in Elementary Grades book provides an 4th grade Curriculum Map with Projects as an example:
Another suggestion the book made is to use curriculum guides or scope and sequence documents that contain standards that are “unpacked” into discrete skills and pieces of knowledge. You can use this specific guidance to design project products, assessments, and lesson that align closely with the standards.
Selecting 21st Century Skills
Communication, collaboration, and critical thinking/problem solving are the three most important 21st century skills called the “3Cs”. According to PBL in Elementary Grades book these skills and several others are a natural fit with PBL. The book recommends not to assume students are gaining these skills because you designed a challenging project. These skills should be taught and assessed in a project.
PBL in Elementary Grades book notes you only teach and assess two of the skills if this is your first project. One is oral communication (making presentation) because all projects include presenting to a public audience as an essential element. Presentation skills are called for in the Common Core Standards for English Language Arts, and they are straightforward to teach and assess.
Collaboration or working in teams is the other skill that is easy to teach and assess. You probably are familiar with group work and cooperative learning, so you already have some basics tools in your toolbox.
PBL in Elementary Grades book emphasizes the 3Cs are important for success in the 21st century, and that these skills can be taught and assessed in projects. See examples below:
Collaboration
Take responsibility for the quality and timeliness of his or her own work; uses feedback; stays on task during group work.
Accepts shared responsibility for the work of the group; helps improve the quality of the work an understanding of other members.
Applies or encourages the use of strategies for facilitating discussion and decision making.
Manages project by identifying and prioritizing goals and tasks, creating timelines, organizing resources, and monitoring progress.
Respects the ideas, opinion, abilities, values, and feeling of other group members; Works well with diverse group members; Encourages group cohesion by using conflict management strategies.
Communication (When making a presentation)
Organizes ideas and develops content appropriate to audiences and situations.
Uses effective oral presentation skills.
Create media/visual aids that enhance content delivery.
Gauges audience reaction and/or understanding and adjusts presentation appropriately.
Responds to questions appropriately.
Critical Thinking/Problem Solving
Recognizes and defines problems accurately; raises relevant questions and issues, formulating them clearly and precisely.
Gathers pertinent information from a variety of sources; evaluates the quality of information (source, validity, bias).
Organizes, analyzes, and synthesizes information to develop well-reasoned conclusions and solutions, judging them against relevant criteria.
Considers alternatives; recognizes and assesses assumptions, implications, and practical consequences.
College and Career Readiness Standards for English Language Arts: Speaking and Listening: Presentation of Knowledge and Ideas Continuum from Kindergarten to Fifth Grade. See Below:
Hallermann, Sara; Larmer, John; Mergendoller PhD, John. PBL in the Elementary Grades: Step-by-Step Guidance, Tools and Tips for Standards-Focused K-5 Projects (p. 32). Buck Institute for Education. Kindle Edition.
Teaching students how to think critically and solve problems is more challenging. These are complex skills that cut across several content areas, and most teachers only have experience with instruction that emphasizes factual and procedural knowledge. Assessing critical thinking/problem solving is also challenging, because it is not readily observable.
Hallermann and Mergendoller suggest other skills might be encouraged in your project, but not explicitly taught and assessed — such as creativity or global awareness. If you’re ambitious, and it’s not your first project, you may wish to add more skills to your list of goals, such as project management, the use of various technological tools, and cross-cultural competence. These are all teachable and assessable. Note that if you want to teach multiple 21st century skills, your project will need to be longer, to build enough time during the project to practice and assess the skills.
Hallermann, Sara; Larmer, John; Mergendoller PhD, John. PBL in the Elementary Grades: Step-by-Step Guidance, Tools and Tips for Standards-Focused K-5 Projects (p. 33). Buck Institute for Education. Kindle Edition.
Student feedback plays a crucial role in the educational process. When delivered effectively, it allows students to recognize their strengths and areas for improvement. It not only highlights their achievements, but also guides them toward growth. By appreciating the value of student feedback and employing effective feedback techniques, educators can enhance the learning experience. This creates an environment where students feel empowered and achieve their highest potential.
Key Highlights
Effective feedback is crucial for enhancing the learning process and boosting student performance.
This blog explores the impact of feedback, different types of feedback, and strategies for delivering it effectively.
Discover how personalized feedback and technology can be leveraged to maximize student learning.
It also addresses the challenges of providing feedback, such as navigating negative feedback and ensuring timeliness.
Lastly, the blog emphasizes the importance of measuring the impact of feedback and using it for continuous improvement in education.
Understanding the Impact of Feedback For Student Learning
Constructive feedback from the University of Texas plays a crucial role in enhancing student performance and fostering a positive learning environment. It highlights students’ strengths, as well as areas needing improvement. When students can identify where they can grow, they are more inclined to take charge of their own education and strive for better results.
Additionally, feedback helps students develop critical thinking abilities and deepen their grasp of the subjects they are studying. By providing clear and helpful advice, effective feedback enables students to better understand their learning goals.
Exploring the Role of Feedback in the Learning Process
Feedback serves as a guiding compass for students, directing them toward their learning objectives. Formative feedback takes place throughout the learning journey, while summative feedback is provided at the conclusion of a learning unit. This feedback allows students to adapt their learning strategies and deepen their comprehension as they progress. It’s an invaluable tool that enables quick adjustments and reinforces their understanding of key concepts at critical moments.
Additionally, feedback plays a crucial role in fostering metacognitive skills, encouraging students to reflect on their learning processes. They can identify their strengths and areas needing improvement. This self-awareness is vital for cultivating a growth mindset, empowering students to tackle challenges and view mistakes as valuable opportunities for growth.
Incorporating regular feedback into the learning experience generates a cycle of continuous improvement, empowering students to take an active role in their educational journey.
The Psychological Effects of Feedback on Students
The impact of feedback on students’ minds can significantly shape their motivation and engagement levels. When feedback is positive, genuine, and straightforward, it boosts students’ confidence and fosters a strong connection to learning. By acknowledging their efforts and celebrating their successes, teachers can instill pride in students, motivating them to strive for even greater achievements.
However, it’s essential to strike a balance between encouraging and constructive criticism. Feedback should promote growth without causing frustration. When giving constructive advice, pinpoint specific areas for improvement and provide practical suggestions, rather than simply highlighting mistakes.
Ultimately, the goal of feedback is to cultivate a supportive learning environment. This approach empowers students to embrace challenges, learn from their missteps, and achieve their full potential.
Encourage Continuous Feedback from Students
Encourage regular feedback from students is essential for developing a dynamic and adaptable learning environment that caters to their needs. This continuous exchange not only fosters open dialogue, but also empowers students to share their opinions on teaching strategies and learning resources. By consistently gathering input through surveys, suggestion boxes, or guided discussions, teachers can gain valuable insights into how students feel and experience. This approach helps pinpoint areas that might require changes, and reinforces the idea that student input is important in education. Moreover, nurturing a culture of reciprocated feedback motivates students to take charge of their learning journey. They begin to value the feedback they receive and feel inspired to share their thoughts to improve classroom interactions. By acting on student feedback, educators foster a collaborative relationship that encourages ongoing enhancement of the learning experience for everyone involved.
Types of Feedback and Their Effectiveness
Feedback comes in various forms, each with unique advantages and considerations to keep in mind. Understanding these different types enables teachers to blend their approaches and select the most suitable one for specific situations or educational objectives, always considering the assignment’s intentions. Tailoring feedback to align with the context and individual needs of students is crucial to be effective.
In the upcoming sections, we will explore several types of feedback. We’ll look at their characteristics and examine how they influence student learning.
Positive vs. Constructive Feedback: A Comparative Analysis
Positive feedback and constructive feedback are two fundamental types of feedback, each playing a distinct role in student learning. While positive feedback aims to reinforce desired behaviors and attitudes, constructive feedback focuses on identifying areas for improvement and providing further clarification and guidance for growth.
Types of Feedback
Purpose
Example
Positive Feedback
To reinforce positive behavior and build confidence.
“Excellent work on your essay! Your arguments were well-structured and supported by strong evidence.”
Constructive Feedback
To identify areas for improvement and provide guidance for growth.
“Your essay shows good understanding of the topic, but the conclusion could be strengthened by summarizing the key arguments more concisely.”
Effectively utilizing both types of feedback helps create a balanced and supportive learning environment. Educators must recognize the importance of acknowledging and strengthening positive progress, while also providing specific and actionable guidance for improvement.
Immediate vs. Delayed Feedback and Student Performance
The timing of feedback plays a significant role in student performance. When feedback is provided immediately after an activity, it enables students to identify and correct errors, enhancing their comprehension. This approach is particularly beneficial for tasks that require immediate application of their knowledge.
On the other hand, feedback after a delay can be more appropriate for larger projects or assessments. This allows teachers to offer more comprehensive insights and support, addressing a wide range of skills and concepts, as students have had the chance to reflect on their work.
Ultimately, the choice between immediate and delayed feedback should be based on learners’ needs, the complexity of the task, and the specific learning objectives in mind.
Strategies for Delivering Effective Feedback
Giving effective feedback requires careful thought and a focus on the student. Teachers should use methods that make everything clear, encourage thinking, and support a growth mindset. When teachers use these methods, they can create a feedback process that truly matters and helps every student.
The next sections look at practical strategies teachers can use to improve their feedback practices. This will help students take ownership of their learning journey.
Creating Actionable Feedback for Students
Creating actionable feedback for students is essential for fostering a learning environment where growth and improvement are prioritized. Actionable feedback goes beyond mere praise or criticism; it provides clear, specific, and targeted suggestions tailored to each student’s needs. To ensure feedback is effective, teachers should focus on the steps students can take to enhance their understanding or performance in a given task. Utilizing examples from a student’s work can illustrate the points made, making it easier for them to recognize how to apply the suggested changes in future assignments. Moreover, empowering students to reflect on their feedback fosters independence and critical thinking, enabling them to set personal goals for improvement. By making feedback actionable, educators not only enhance students’ skills, but also help them develop a proactive approach to their learning journey, cultivating an atmosphere that values continuous growth and self-improvement.
Creating a Culture of Feedback
Creating a culture of feedback is essential for fostering a supportive and growth-oriented learning environment. When students and educators prioritize feedback, it transforms the educational landscape into a collaborative space where learning is continuous and evolving. This culture encourages open dialogue, allowing students to feel safe to express their thoughts and concerns without fear of judgment. Teachers should model constructive feedback practices, demonstrating how to give and receive feedback effectively, which lays the groundwork for students to engage in meaningful peer reviews. Furthermore, integrating feedback into daily routines—through discussions, reflections, and regular check-ins—reinforces its importance and normalizes the practice. By emphasizing the value of feedback, educators cultivate a mindset of improvement, where both students and teachers see challenges as opportunities for growth, paving the way for enhanced learning outcomes and deeper engagement in the educational process.
Partnering with Students for Feedback
Partnering with students for feedback creates a dynamic learning environment where both educators and learners collaborate to enhance the educational experience. By involving students in the feedback process, educators cultivate ownership and accountability over their learning. This partnership allows students to share their insights and perspectives, which can lead to more tailored and effective feedback. Additionally, it encourages students to take an active role in their evaluation, as they become more aware of their strengths and areas for growth. Workshops and structured discussions can facilitate this partnership, providing students with a platform to express their thoughts and suggest improvements. By fostering this two-way dialogue, educators can not only refine their feedback practices, but also empower students to become reflective practitioners, thus nurturing a continuous cycle of growth and improvement in learning outcomes.
Aligning Feedback with Learning Objectives
Aligning feedback with learning objectives is crucial to ensure that students understand what they have learned, but also why it matters. When feedback directly relates to specific learning goals, it provides students with a clear framework for evaluation and improvement. This connection helps students see the relevance of the feedback they receive, and motivates them to engage more deeply with the material. Educators can enhance this alignment by clearly communicating the objectives at the start of each lesson and consistently referring back to them during feedback sessions. For instance, when discussing a student’s work, teachers can highlight how certain aspects met or missed the established learning targets, offering precise suggestions for improvement tied directly to these objectives. This reinforces the purpose of their efforts and fosters a growth mindset, as students understand that feedback is not just a critique, but a valuable tool in their learning journey.
Utilizing Technology for Efficient Feedback Delivery
In today’s digital world, technology gives us many tools to help with feedback in higher education. These tools make the feedback process easier and save teachers time. They also improve the quality and effect of the feedback. Using learning management systems or interactive platforms, teachers can provide timely and focused feedback that meets different learning styles.
For example, platforms that support audio or video feedback create a more personal and fun experience for students. Tools that allow real-time feedback during online activities help students understand and correct mistakes immediately, which can be especially beneficial in larger classes. Teachers can also use online rubrics and assessment tools for clear and regular feedback on assignments.
By using technology wisely, teachers can give feedback that boosts student learning and creates a more engaging classroom experience.
Incorporating Peer Feedback for Enhanced Learning
Peer feedback is a helpful way to improve learning. It allows students to learn from each other. They also get different viewpoints on their work. When students participate in peer feedback, they build critical thinking skills. They also strengthen their communication skills. This helps them understand learning objectives better.
Here’s how peer feedback improves the learning experience:
Multiple Perspectives: Students get ideas from their peers. This helps them see more about the topic and find areas to work on that they might have missed.
Enhanced Communication Skills: Giving and receiving feedback in a friendly way teaches important communication skills.
Increased Engagement and Ownership: Peer feedback makes learning more active. It encourages students to take ownership of their learning by sharing and using constructive tips.
By adding peer feedback to the lessons, teachers create a teamwork-focused environment. This helps both students give feedback and those receiving it.
Challenges in Providing Feedback and How to Overcome Them
Giving good feedback can be hard. Teachers often deal with issues like not having enough time, handling negative feedback, and making sure students understand and use the useful feedback. These problems can make feedback less effective and slow student progress.
Still, if teachers recognize these challenges and use plans to fix them, they can build a system for feedback that works better and helps both them and their students.
Navigating the Pitfalls of Negative Feedback
While feedback helps students grow, negative feedback can hurt them if it’s not given carefully. This can lower their motivation and self-esteem. When you criticize a student’s work without clear ways to improve, it can be discouraging.
To avoid negative feedback problems, try to give it in a positive way next time. Focus on chances for improvement, not just mistakes. Instead of saying, “This is wrong,” you could say, “I see where you’re going, but consider this approach.” Give clear examples and specific steps. This way, you help the student see how to improve and feel confident in doing it.
Always remember, feedback should guide and encourage students, not bring them down. When you handle negative feedback with care and focus on solutions, you help students build a growth mindset. This empowers them to face challenges better.
Ensuring Timeliness and Relevance in Feedback Provision
Timeliness and relevance are important for good feedback. When feedback is given a long time after a task is done, it loses its value. Students might have moved on or forgotten details about their work. Quick feedback helps students think about it and use it for future tasks.
Make sure your feedback is related to the learning objectives and the standards for the task. Avoid general comments that don’t give clear insights or point out specific areas to improve. Focusing on a few key parts helps students work better and see real progress, making their learning experience more positive and productive.
By giving timely and relevant feedback, teachers show they care about their students’ progress, and that the feedback is meant to help them grow and understand better.
Measuring the Impact of Feedback on Student Achievement
Measuring how feedback affects students is important for teachers. This helps them figure out if their feedback works and if they need to change it. By looking at how students react to feedback and using that information in future lessons, teachers show they care about the students and want to keep improving.
Using different tools, like quizzes, surveys, and self-reviews, can give helpful ideas on how students grasp and use the features of effective feedback given. Teachers can then check this information to find trends and spots where they might need to improve their feedback methods.
Tools and Techniques for Assessing Feedback Effectiveness
A range of tools and methods can be used to check how feedback helps students learn. These methods do more than just collect student work after giving feedback. They promote thinking, discussion, and real use of the feedback received.
One common way is to use exit tickets at the end of a lesson or unit. In this, students write down what they have learned and how the feedback helped them understand better. Another way is to encourage self-reflection. Students can use journals or online platforms to share the learning process and talk directly about the feedback.
By using these assessments, teachers can understand how their feedback makes a difference. They can adjust their teaching style to meet the different needs of their students. This ongoing process keeps feedback as a strong tool for learning and growth.
Feedback as a Tool for Continuous Improvement in Education
In the changing world of education, it’s important to keep improving. Quality feedback is key in this process. When teachers embrace a culture of feedback, they show they want to give their students the best learning experience.
This means teachers should stay open to student feedback about teaching methods, course content, and tests. Using student suggestions can help make learning more engaging and effective. Teachers should also seek feedback from their colleagues and participate in professional development that centers around feedback. This can give them useful insights and help them improve their teaching practices.
In the end, using feedback to keep improving helps both teachers and students. It creates a lively and responsive educational environment.
Reflecting on Your Feedback Practices as an Educator
As teachers, it’s important to think about how we give feedback. This helps us support our students better. We need to look at our methods often. We should be open to new ideas and remember that giving good feedback is something we keep working on.
Ask yourself: Is your feedback quick, clear, and helpful during office hours? Does it help students take charge of their learning and inspire them to get better? By looking closely at how we give feedback and finding ways to improve, we can create a better learning space for our students.
Conclusion
Student learning greatly benefits from effective feedback, as it enables educators to enhance the educational environment. Tailoring feedback, leveraging technology, and incorporating peer interactions are excellent strategies to keep students invested in their studies. It’s crucial to address challenges like negative feedback and ensure timely responses. This approach can significantly aid students in their academic journeys. Additionally, continually refining feedback practices can lead to remarkable student accomplishments. As educators, when we thoughtfully consider how to deliver feedback and experiment with new approaches, we enrich the learning experience. Let’s collaborate to ensure that feedback becomes a fundamental aspect of student success.
Questions to Consider When Choosing Scaffolding Strategies
Karin Hess, author of the article ‘How to be Strategic with Scaffolding Strategies’, wants educators to consider this question when choosing a scaffolding strategy:
Why did I choose this strategy?
Does it match my learning target? and
How will it optimize learning for some or all of my students?
Previous Post
3 Myths about Scaffolding
Hess shares some ideas about making good choices, but first Hess wants to clear up 3 common myths about scaffolding:
Myth #1: Scaffolding is the Same as Differentiation
Many teachers – and even some educational resources – often mix scaffolding with differentiation, but they are distinct. To help remember the difference, you can think of scaffolding as providing the necessary support to complete a task, while differentiation offers students various options regarding the tasks they can undertake.
When instruction is differentiated, students select from various assignments that are often similar in difficulty. I first intentionally used differentiation during my time teaching middle school. I developed assignment menus that catered to different content (varying texts, materials, scenarios, or subjects), the processes involved (levels of engagement with the material, whether working solo or in pairs, etc.), and the products that students created to demonstrate their understanding. Tools like choice boards, menus, and activity stations are frequently employed throughout a unit to present optional tasks for students.
On the other hand, scaffolding strategies are designed to help each student effectively engage with grade-level content, complete assignments ranging from basic to advanced, and build their confidence and independence as learners.
Myth #2: Scaffolding is always temporary
In fact, many scaffolding techniques—like dividing a task into manageable pieces or collaboratively creating an anchor chart to enhance understanding—can be applied later, even as tasks become more complex. Scaffolds aren’t just for students who need extra help. Even top-performing adults break intricate tasks into smaller segments and rely on models and peer feedback to better grasp new concepts. Think of it this way: a painter always utilizes some form of scaffolding when working on a ceiling.
Myth 3: Scaffolding is used to change the intended Rigor
A scaffolding approach can lighten the cognitive load on a learner’s working memory during educational activities, without altering the challenge level of the task.
For example, when a complex text is read aloud or illustrated as a graphic novel, students are relieved from the need to fully use their working memory to decipher unfamiliar words for understanding the text’s meaning. Instead, they might take sketch notes while listening, capturing essential ideas to facilitate later summarization, discussion, or explanation of more intricate concepts.
While decoding skills are vital, the primary focus of this learning activity isn’t solely on decoding words. Similarly, when a student uses a calculator to perform calculations with large numbers or decimals, they can verify their estimates without the cognitive burden of manually calculating the same operations.
Understanding the learning objectives helps educators identify the most suitable scaffolds for the lesson and specific students—essentially, placing the scaffolding activity in their Zone of Proximal Development (ZPD). Scaffolding is aimed at ensuring that even if a student encounters difficulties, those challenges are constructive.
Consider scaffolding as a bridge that can either (a) enhance content accessibility (such as “chunking” texts, conducting focused discussions, or building background knowledge) or (b) simplify multi-step tasks (like collaborative data collection or breaking tasks into smaller, manageable parts with checkpoints).
Determining the Right Time for Scaffolding
Educators can benefit from considering three main areas of support that help students build the skills necessary for tackling more complex tasks or grasping difficult concepts:
enhancing content understanding,
improving executive function, and
fostering language and vocabulary skills.
Effective scaffolding at one Depth of Knowledge (DOK) level typically helps students progress to the subsequent DOK level. Below, Hess outlines various strategies for each DOK Level tailored to different teaching goals. (For a comprehensive collection of strategies, be sure to download Karin’s PDF.)
Scaffolding Purpose 1: Enhancing Understanding and Linking to Key Concepts
Various techniques aimed at enriching learning can easily emerge from activities focused on improving language abilities or fostering executive function. For example, collaborating with students to create an anchor chart outlining the steps for tackling a non-routine math problem not only bolsters executive functioning, but also serves as a useful reference. This chart can remind students of each step as they approach new challenges.
Scaffolding Techniques to Enhance Learning Across Various DOK Levels
DOK 1 – The “DAILY 10” Playlist
The role of prior knowledge in improving reading comprehension and developing schema is crucial. To implement this technique, create a playlist featuring at least six short printed and non-printed materials on a subject (like images, political cartoons, articles, or relevant websites tied to social studies or a science unit) for students at the week’s start.
Each day, for a maximum of ten minutes, students—either individually or in small groups—select one resource to read or listen to and jot down some notes. These notes are not graded. Encourage class discussions and journal entries to link this expanding background knowledge to the current unit of study.
DOK 3 – Carousel Feedback
This approach reframes carousel brainstorming, where small groups rotate through different stations, brainstorming ideas on various subtopics. They record their thoughts on large chart papers for the next group to read and contribute to.
The teacher sets up 4 or 5 large posters, each featuring a unique question prompt or problem-solving task. Students are grouped in a diverse arrangement, each group using a different colored marker for their answers. They start by reading the problem at their table and working on the chart paper to find a solution.
After a few minutes (before they complete their task), the teacher signals for time, and the groups rotate to tackle a new problem. Upon arrival, they review the previous group’s work and discuss it among themselves. They then determine whether the last group’s solution was correct and use a new color marker to either continue solving the problem if it was right or to make adjustments if they spot an error. If corrections are needed, they add a note explaining the mistake and the rationale for the correction.
When time is called again, the groups rotate for a third time, repeating the checking and justification process as before. In the final round of rotations, the groups create a justification for their solution, relying on calculations and notes provided by other teams. This carousel approach fosters meaningful discussions and encourages collaborative reasoning backed by evidence.
Purpose of Scaffolding 2: Enhancing Executive Function and Skill Application
Students who struggle with executive function often find it challenging to stay focused and engaged in dealing with long texts and complex tasks. This skill set also plays a crucial role in goal setting, monitoring progress, and fostering a positive self-image as learners. Executive functions encompass various skills that help students start, track, and complete intricate multi-step projects.
Scaffolding strategies can help in several areas:
Initiation – The ability to kick off a task or activity while generating ideas, responses, or finding solutions (e.g., collaborative brainstorming sessions).
Working Memory – The ability to retain information for engaging with longer texts (e.g., breaking texts into manageable chunks).
Planning and Organization – The skill to handle both current and future tasks demands (e.g., maintaining learning logs).
Self-Monitoring – The capacity to assess one’s own performance and compare it to established standards or expectations (e.g., through conference discussions).
Supportive Strategies for Executive Function at Varying DOK Levels
DOK 2: A Card Pyramid for Information Summarization
The card pyramid technique uses numbered sticky notes or index cards to dismantle information from a text. Ideally, partners collaborate to construct the pyramid, taking turns to verbally summarize their findings, before penning down a written summary.
DOK 3: Crafting a Mathematical Argument
Teaching how to create a mathematical argument can be as challenging as learning it. In this approach, partners split their paper vertically. On the left side, students methodically work through the steps to solve the problem, while on the right, they articulate the reasoning behind each step or explain how it works. contributed to their solution (e.g., my diagram illustrates the division of the candy bar; I’ve labeled each fractional part to clarify…). This scaffolding method is beneficial, as it deconstructs the path to the solution, allowing for a more thoughtful explanation of the reasoning behind each action.
Scaffolding Purpose 3: Nurturing Language and Vocabulary Growth
Developing vocabulary and language skills is crucial for understanding across all subjects. One effective strategy for enhancing vocabulary is to emphasize and reinforce the key language necessary for learning in each content area. Teachers can informally boost language development by using visuals and tangible models to activate prior knowledge, color-coding to highlight significance or differences (like anchor charts, sentence stems, or paragraph frames for multi-digit number place value), facilitating meaningful discussions, and demonstrating their thought processes aloud.
Using multi-sensory techniques can help students develop their language skills. However, it’s important to avoid overwhelming them with too many methods simultaneously, or relying on strategies that don’t easily carry over to future learning. A charming visual of a pumpkin or cookie may not effectively help students understand paragraph or essay writing compared to a structured anchor chart or a color-coded paragraph frame with clear visual cues.
Hess enjoys introducing TBEAR through texts familiar to students, such as fairy tales or pieces they’ve read in class before. Teachers at all grade levels have used or modified TBEAR, and have found it particularly effective for students struggling with language proficiency. In both whole-class settings and partner work, students can use TBEAR to help them find text evidence and prepare for discussions or writing assignments. For example, middle school teachers I’ve collaborated with had students develop and display anchor charts for important math vocabulary after analyzing these words through TBEAR.
TBEAR smoothly supports students in progressing from DOK level 1 to levels 2, 3, or 4, and it’s easy to recall what each letter represents:
T: Create a Topic sentence/Thesis statement/or claim (DOK 1); or define a vocabulary Term or concept.
B: Succinctly summarize the text to act as a bridge to your evidence (DOK 2); or rephrase the meaning in your own words.
E: Find text Evidence/Examples (DOK 2); or offer both examples and non-examples when defining specific terms.
A: Analyze each example or piece of text evidence; include additional details to explain why the evidence backs up your thesis/claim (DOK 3).
R: Share a key takeaway (DOK 1 or 2) or a reflection that might extend from DOK 3 to DOK 4, such as links to the world, personal experiences, or ties to additional resources.
Support for Everyone
True equity starts with the understanding that all students can and should progress beyond memorizing routines and gaining superficial knowledge in a subject. This is particularly important for students with learning disabilities and those who speak multiple languages.
Research indicates every student benefits from daily chances to express their creativity, interpret information and ideas, pose questions, engage in research, and develop their own insights through meaningful discussions.
In education, being clear is important. When learners know what is expected and how to succeed, they feel more motivated and confident. This is why creating success criteria together matters. By getting learners involved in deciding what success looks like, teachers can help them feel responsible. This approach also brings openness and a common understanding into the learning space.
Key Highlights
1. Co-constructing success criteria involves learners in defining what quality work looks like.
2. This practice promotes a shared understanding of learning targets and empowers students to take ownership.
3. By actively participating in this process, learners can better self-assess and monitor their progress.
4. Co-constructing success criteria leads to clearer expectations, reduces anxiety, and fosters a more collaborative learning environment.
5. It’s an ongoing process that requires flexibility, reflection, and continuous refinement.
Co-Creating Success Criteria Understanding Its Importance
A key part of good learning is knowing what success means. That’s why it’s important to build success criteria together. This teamwork ensures teachers and students see quality work in the same way and understand what it takes to achieve it. Rather than just telling students what the criteria are, teachers involve them in real conversations. They help students look at examples, point out important traits, and explain what success means to them. This teamwork approach, supported by groups like the Core Collaborative Learning Lab, focuses on the student’s voice. It helps students take charge of their learning journey.
What Is Co-Construction in Educational Settings?
Co-construction in education is a process where teachers and students work together. They join forces to understand the learning target and how to achieve it. This method is different from the old way, where teachers only decide what success looks like. Instead of just giving out a rubric, co-construction helps students look at models. They learn to spot the key parts of quality work and express their ideas. This active role helps learners understand the learning goals better. It also gives them a chance to take charge of their learning. When teachers use co-construction, they create a friendly and focused space for learning. Here, students are actively involved in their own education journey.
The Impact of Shared Success Criteria on Learning Outcomes
Imagine a classroom in an elementary school where students know what is expected of them. They can easily explain what makes a good presentation, a well-written paragraph, or a math problem solved correctly. This clear understanding helps improve their learning. When students decide what success looks like, they feel more involved, excited, and interested in their own learning. This leads to a better grasp of ideas, higher scores on tests, and a bigger desire to try new things. Sharing success criteria helps give helpful feedback and self-assess. Learners can use these criteria to keep track of their progress, find things they can work on, and celebrate what they have achieved.
Co-Constructing Kick-Starts a Metacognitive Process
Kara Vandas, author of the article “How to Co-Construct Success Criteria in Education“, believes that co-constructing success criteria not only enhances student engagement, but also ignites a powerful meta-cognitive process. When learners define what success looks like, they begin to reflect on their own understanding, learning strategies, and areas for growth. This active participation cultivates a mindset of self-awareness and critical thinking, allowing students to evaluate their progress in relation to the established criteria. For instance, as students discuss and refine the criteria, they are encouraged to consider questions like, “How does my work align with our agreed standards?” or “What strategies can I employ to improve?” This self-reflective practice not only deepens their comprehension of the subject matter, but also fosters accountability and ownership over their learning journey. Through this meta-cognitive lens, students become more adept at monitoring their performance and making informed decisions about their learning, ultimately leading to more meaningful improvement and achievement.
Enhancing Student Engagement and Ownership Through Co-Construction
Vandas explains that enhancing student engagement and ownership through co-construction is a transformative process that allows learners to play an active role in their education. When students are involved in creating success criteria, they feel greater belonging and responsibility toward their learning. This participatory approach fosters intrinsic motivation, as students recognize that their input directly impacts their educational journey. By engaging in discussions and collaborating with their peers, learners develop essential skills, such as critical thinking, communication, and teamwork. Moreover, when students see their ideas reflected in the success criteria, they become more invested in achieving those goals. As a result, classrooms become vibrant communities where learners are not just recipients of knowledge, but active contributors to their own success. Such an environment not only enhances engagement, but also cultivates lifelong learning habits, empowering students to take ownership of their achievements and prepare them for future challenges.
Preparing to Co-Creating Success Criteria
Transitioning to a co-constructed model requires some preparation. In their book Clarity for learning, Almarode & Vandas suggest you start by thinking about your own teaching methods and belief systems related to learning. How can you change from telling students what to do to letting them take charge of their own learning?
Think about ways to create a safe and supportive learning space. In this space, students should feel easy about sharing their thoughts and viewpoints. Co-construction is a journey. It requires a focus on students and a readiness to work together.
The What, Why, and How of Sharing Clarity With Learners
Sharing clarity with learners about success criteria is essential for their understanding and progress. By involving learners in co-creating success criteria, you empower them to take ownership of their learning journey. This collaborative approach not only enhances student engagement, but also fosters deeper comprehension of the learning objectives. When learners actively define what success looks like, they develop a sense of purpose and direction, leading to more meaningful learning outcomes. The process of co-creating success criteria ultimately nurtures a positive learning environment where learners feel valued and motivated to achieve their goals.
Essential Resources and Tools for Effective Collaboration
Effective teamwork works best when you have the right resources and tools. To help your classroom get the most from working together, think about adding these:
Exemplars: Collect examples of student work. This should include both good samples and those that need some help. Use these for discussion.
Anchor Charts: Create visual guides for the shared criteria. Make sure to place them where everyone can see them, and use them often.
Digital Tools: Use online platforms to brainstorm together. You can try shared documents, virtual whiteboards, or mind-mapping software. This is great for getting ideas from students who are remote or not in sync.
By offering different tools, we ensure that all learners can find resources that fit their needs and ways of learning. This helps create a more inclusive environment during the teamwork process.
Identifying Stakeholders in the Co-Creating Success Criteria Process
Effective co-construction happens not just in the classroom. Teachers and students are key players, but it’s essential to see other people who can help with this teamwork.
Parents, for example, can be important. They can encourage the learning intention at home, give support, and talk about the co-constructed criteria.
Bringing in other educators, like special education teachers, instructional coaches, or librarians, can improve this process. They can share different views and help include all learners.
Practical Strategies for Co-Constructing Success Criteria
Co-constructing success criteria in the classroom can be a transformative experience, but it requires practical strategies to ensure effectiveness and inclusivity. In her article, Sharing Clarity with Students: 15 Ways to Co=Construct Success Criteria, Kara Vandas suggests starting by implementing regular check-ins, where students can voice their thoughts and experiences regarding the criteria. This approach can involve quick surveys or informal discussions, which will help you gauge the students’ understanding and comfort levels. Additionally, consider utilizing peer feedback sessions where students share their work, providing constructive feedback based on the established success criteria. This not only reinforces the criteria, but also fosters a collaborative learning environment. Incorporating visual aids, such as graphic organizers or anchor charts, can further support students in recognizing the components of quality work. Finally, continuously revisiting and refining the criteria based on student input ensures the standards remain relevant and resonate with their learning experiences. By consistently applying these practical strategies, educators can effectively co-construct success criteria that empower students and enhance their educational journey.
Utilizing Success Criteria Templates for Effective Co-Construction
How to Co-Construct Success Criteria in Education article suggests that utilizing success criteria templates for effective co-construction not only streamlines the process, but also supports a multi-faceted understanding of expectations among students. These templates serve as a structured outline, allowing learners and educators to collaboratively define and visualize what success looks like in different contexts. By providing pre-formed categories and descriptors, templates can guide discussions and help focus on key attributes of quality work. As students fill in the templates together, they engage in meaningful dialogue about what each criterion entails, promoting a deeper understanding of the subject matter. Moreover, these templates can be adapted to cater to various learning styles and levels, making the co-construction process more inclusive. Ultimately, leveraging success criteria templates fosters clarity, consistency, and empowerment, ensuring that all students have the tools they need to take ownership of their learning and strive towards excellence.
Co-Creating Success Criteria: A Step-by-Step Guide
Embracing this team-focused way of working can feel tough, but it doesn’t have to be. To make it easier, think about these simple steps. Keep in mind that setting success criteria should be a conversation that keeps going, rather than just something you do once.
If you use this easy guide and include examples, talks, and thoughts, you can build a lively learning space. In this space, everyone will feel sure and strong.
Step 1: Establishing Clear Learning Goals with Students
The key to successful teamwork in learning starts with setting clear goals with your learners. First, share the learning aims using simple language. This way, students can understand why what they are learning matters.
Next, invite questions and spark a discussion. Ask students what they already know about the topic and what they want to learn. This helps them connect their earlier knowledge and prepare them for a deeper learning journey.
Keep in mind that setting clear goals is not about giving orders. It’s about clearly showing what you want to achieve and making sure students engage from the start.
Step 2: Facilitating Discussions Around Success Criteria
Start by showing students exemplars. These are examples of student work at different quality levels. Ask questions like, “What makes this work successful?” or “What could we improve?”
Encourage learners to think carefully. They should find important parts and explain their thoughts. These discussions help learners understand better what high-quality work looks like.
Step 3: Documenting and Refining Success Criteria Together
As discussions unfold, capture the emerging understandings in a clear and accessible format. Co-create an anchor chart, a shared document, or a simple table that outlines the co-constructed success criteria.
Criteria
What it Looks Like
Clear and Focused Writing
Sentences are easy to understand. The main idea is evident.
Strong Evidence
Supporting details are relevant and convincing.
Effective Organization
Ideas flow logically. There’s a clear beginning, middle, and end.
Regularly revisit and refine these criteria as learners gain experience and deepen their understanding. Encourage learners to reflect on their work, provide feedback on the criteria, and suggest revisions. This iterative process ensures that the criteria remain relevant, student-centered, and reflective of the evolving learning journey.
Conclusion
In conclusion, working together to create success criteria in schools encourages students to get involved and take responsibility for their learning. This approach improves their learning results. By engaging everyone, setting clear goals, and working on the criteria as a team, we build a shared feeling of success. It’s important to empower students through good teamwork and ensure everyone’s voice counts. Together, we can create a more inclusive and enriching learning environment. If you’re ready to start this journey of making success criteria together, get the right tools and embrace the amazing power of teamwork. Let’s work together for a brighter future!
Creating a place where all students feel included and can take part in their learning is important for their growth in school. When teachers use self-assessment, they help students take charge of their own learning. This builds a sense of responsibility and helps them learn to guide themselves. This guide will look at helpful ways to use self-assessment in your classroom.
Key Highlights
Empower students to take ownership of their learning by implementing self-assessment techniques.
Discover the benefits of self-assessment, such as increased student motivation, engagement, and metacognitive skills.
Explore practical examples of self-assessment tools, including learning logs, rubric self-assessments, and exit tickets.
Learn how to effectively introduce self-assessment to students and provide ongoing support throughout the process.
Encourage a growth mindset, where students view challenges as valuable learning experiences.
Understanding the Basics of Self-Assessment
Self-assessment is a helpful way for students to think about their own work. They look at what they have done and see how good it is. They also find ways to improve. This isn’t just about giving their own grades. Instead, students compare their work to set rules, check how they did, and plan how to get better with their understanding and skills.
When students take part in self-assessment, they build important skills that help them think about their learning. They become more aware of how they learn, what they are good at, and what they need to work on. This understanding helps them take control of their learning journey. They can then make smart choices about how they move forward in school.
Defining Self-Assessment in Educational Contexts
According to Benefits and Examples of Student Self-Assessments article self-assessment in education means that students look at their own work or performance. They do this by using specific rules or standards to help them. This practice encourages students to be more involved in their own learning. They reflect on what they understand and see where they can improve. Self-assessment isn’t just about grading. It includes different methods, like writing journal entries, using self-evaluation charts, and getting feedback from peers.
Doing self-assessment helps students learn more deeply and understand better. When they think about their own work, they learn the subject and the assessment criteria more clearly. As a result, their performance may get better, and they feel a greater sense of achievement.
Using self-assessment in higher education can be very helpful. It allows students to take more control of their learning. This also prepares them for independent study and future work in their careers.
The Significance of Self-Assessment for Learners
Benefits and Examples of Student Self-Assessments article suggests self-assessment helps learners take charge of their education. It gives them a clear way to think about how they are doing. When students look at their own work, they better understand what they do well and what they can work on. This helps them set realistic goals and see their progress.
Also, self-assessment builds a growth mindset. It shifts the focus from grades to the learning process itself. Students who use self-assessment see challenges as chances to grow. They are more likely to keep trying even when things get tough. They know that learning is a journey and that setbacks are just a part of it.
Using self-assessment in the classroom can help students feel more independent and responsible. This can lead to more motivation, better engagement, and a deeper understanding of what they are studying.
Preparing for Self-Assessment: What You Need to Get Started
Before you start self-assessment with your students, you need to make a safe space that supports reflection and growth. First, clearly explain why self-assessment is important and the good things that come from it. Stress that it is meant for learning, not for judging anyone.
Also, give students clear and specific assessment criteria. You can work together to create rubrics or checklists. This will help students know what good work looks like and let them use these tools to fairly assess their own performance.
Identifying Goals and Objectives
Clearly defining learning goals and success criteria is very important before starting self-assessment. First, set specific, measurable, achievable, relevant, and time-bound (SMART) learning goals for the lesson or unit. This helps students know what they are working towards and creates a guide for their self-evaluation.
Next, introduce success criteria. Break the learning goal into smaller and manageable steps. Success criteria show the specific qualities or elements needed to show that a student has reached the learning goal. Involve students in defining success criteria. This helps them feel responsible and understand the expectations better.
By setting clear learning goals and success criteria, you give students the right tools. These tools help them with their learning process and allow them to do useful self-assessments.
Gathering Necessary Tools and Resources
To help students assess themselves, give them useful tools and resources. Having many options allows students to choose what fits their way of learning best. This means every student can get the support they need to do well.
Think about adding:
Checklists: These simple lists help students clearly track their progress and check off all important parts of their assignment or task.
Rubrics: Rubrics show various levels of skill, helping students judge their work fairly and find areas they can improve.
Learning Logs: Learning logs let students think about their learning experiences, write down their progress, and set personal goals.
Step-by-Step Guide to Implementing Self-Assessment
According to Peer and self-assessment article for students Implementing self-assessment in the classroom can be easy. You can start with a clear plan. Slowly add these practices to your teaching. This will help students feel relaxed about checking their own work.
Begin by explaining self-assessment and showing how to do it. Then, give students more responsibility. Make sure to provide clear rules and helpful tools, like checklists or rubrics. These will help them reflect on their work.
Step 1: Introducing Self-Assessment to Learners
When you talk about self-assessment, it’s important to explain why it’s useful and what it can do. Remind everyone that self-assessment is not about giving themselves a grade. It is a helpful way to think about a piece of work and find out how to make it better.
In primary school, start with easy self-assessment activities. For instance, after finishing a writing task, students can read their work again. They can use a checklist to make sure they have used capital letters, punctuation marks, and spaces between words. This will help them get into the habit of looking over their own work to see what can be improved.
As students learn more about self-assessment, you can slowly add more detailed tools and methods. Encourage them to think critically about their learning. Show them examples of how self-assessment can help them be more independent and achieve better results.
Step 2: Creating Effective Self-Assessment Tools
Creating good self-assessment tools is important. They help students evaluate their own work. You should start by involving students in making these tools, if you can. This will give them ownership and help them understand the assessment criteria better.
For younger students, simple checklists work well. Use clear and short phrases that focus on one or two main points. For example, in a writing assignment checklist, you could use items like “I used capital letters at the beginning of each sentence” or “I checked my work for spelling errors.”
Rubrics are another option. They offer a detailed way to evaluate work. Rubrics give specific criteria for different levels of achievement. This helps students look at their own work more fairly. When making rubrics, ask students to help find the key criteria. Make sure the language is clear and easy to grasp.
Step 3: Facilitating the Self-Assessment Process
Effectively facilitating the self-assessment process involves providing clear guidelines, offering constructive feedback, and creating a supportive environment that encourages reflection and growth. Encourage students to view self-assessment as an integral part of their learning process, rather than just another task to complete.
To guide students, provide prompts and questions that encourage thoughtful reflection. For example, ask them to identify the most successful aspect of their work, areas where they faced challenges, or steps they would take to improve their performance. Model the process of providing constructive feedback, focusing on specific examples and suggestions for improvement.
Consider using a table like this to structure self-assessment feedback:
Strength
Area for Improvement
Actionable Step
I organized my ideas logically.
I need to work on my sentence fluency.
I will practice writing different types of sentences.
I used vivid language in my writing.
I need to cite my sources correctly.
I will review
Step 4: Analyzing Self-Assessment Results
To analyze self-assessment results, change how you look at the data. Instead of just gathering it, use it to improve student learning. Tell your students to see the results as helpful advice for bettering themselves, not as a score of their hard work.
Start by looking at the data. Find common strengths and areas where students can grow, whether in the whole class or for individual students. This review can help shape your future lessons. For instance, if many students struggle with certain assessment criteria, you can create lessons focused on those challenges.
Also, urge students to use their results to set personal learning goals. By thinking about their strengths and weaknesses, they can choose specific areas to work on and come up with ways to make progress.
Step 5: Providing Feedback and Support
While students look at their own work, it is very important to guide and support them during this time. Use strategies like peer assessment. This means students give helpful feedback about the work of their peers. It helps create a teamwork environment for learning.
Encourage students to share their thoughts on specific parts of their peers’ work. They should offer tips for improvement instead of just making general comments. Show them how to give constructive feedback. Remind them to use kind words and to provide clear examples and steps for making things better.
By giving regular feedback and building a helpful learning space, you help students see self-assessment as a good tool for their growth. This boosts their confidence and helps them take charge of their studies.
Conclusion
Implementing self-assessment can greatly improve the learning process. It allows students to take control of their own progress. By setting clear goals, giving good tools, and sharing constructive feedback, teachers can create a culture of self-awareness and improvement. Encouraging students to think about their strengths and areas to grow helps them improve their academic performance and develop important life skills. Use self-assessment as a helpful educational tool and see its positive effects on long-term learning outcomes. Remember, helping students with self-assessment is important to make them self-directed learners who succeed in school and in life.
